News On F1 - Formula 1 News, Results, Information and Statistics

Formula 1 Store
F1 Tickets, Tours, Gear
F1 Books
& Biographies

Formula 1 News - June 2005
Statement of F1 Drivers regarding the 2005 United States Grand Prix at Indianapolis

F1 Merchandise
Main Page
Formula 1 News
2009 F1 Schedule
2009 F1 Line-up
2008 F1 Schedule & Results
2008 F1 Line-up
F1 Team Reports
F1 Teams
F1 Drivers
8 'n' Pole
Register - Submit
F1 Regulations
The Forums
Live F1 Coverage
Motorsport Shop
Motorsport Calendar
F1 Merchandise
UK
- USA
F1 Tours
F1 Tickets
F1 Diecast
F1 Videos
F1 Games
F1 Trivia
Past Formula 1 Seasons
2007 F1 Results
2006 F1 Results
2005 F1 Results
2004 F1 Results
2003 F1 Results

2002 F1 Results

2001 F1 Results

2000 F1 Results

1999 F1 Results

1998 F1 Results

1997 F1 Results
Links
Translate
Search
Contact Us
About
Archives
Your Say
Diagnosis & Prognosis
By the Heretic
Controversy Corner
The Real Race
By the Quali-flyer
F1 Testing
2006 World Cup

29 June: Statement of F1 Drivers regarding the 2005 United States Grand Prix at Indianapolis

Introduction

1. We the undersigned drivers make this statement in order to assist the World Motor Sport Council in its consideration of the events at the Indianapolis Grand Prix on Sunday 19th June 2005.

2. We wish in particular to respond to the suggestion that we could have raced with a speed limit (which was never defined) somehow imposed through Turn 13 on cars with Michelin tyres, or that we should have raced but the cars with Michelin tyres should have slowed down voluntarily through this Turn.

3. This suggestion would have been an unprecedented restriction in an F1 race and would have been completely contrary to the competitive essence of Formula One or any motor race that we have ever anticipated in. It would have been unworkable, unpoliceable and above all, unsafe.

Safety

4. Not all cars would have been subject to the speed restriction. At least 6 cars would have been going through Turn 13 as fast as possible i.e. over 320 km per hour. The other cars - they all complied - would have had to slow suddenly going into the Turn, travel at a much slower speed through the Turn then accelerate back to racing speed.

5. This would have meant a huge speed differential between cars at the approach of Turn 13, during Turn 13 and exiting Turn 13. Having cars travelling at dramatically different speeds at the same point on the race track would have been completely chaotic and highly dangerous.

6. There is one good racing line through Turn 13. All of us would have tried to take that line. If a car subject to the restriction had to slow down approaching Turn 13 on the racing line, a car behind it not subject to the restriction would have had to take avoiding action to try to overtake on the Turn off the racing line. This would have put both drivers at considerable risk.

7. Given the competitive nature of a race, the speed restriction would have become a focal point for overtaking. For instance two cars both subject to the speed restriction racing each other going into or coming out of Turn 13 would inevitably have each tried to gain advantage by braking later or accelerating earlier. With other cars racing through the Turn at higher speeds this too would have been chaotic and very unsafe.

8. Given the nature of the race there would also have been a clear incentive for drivers to maintain speeds, particularly if they were close in the race. This would have risked damaging the Michelin tyres which would have created yet further risks.

Practicality

9. The Teams would have been unable to fit a speed limiter which would have operated round Turn 13 in the time available. It would have been left to the Drivers to attempt to accomplish the speed restriction by themselves whist still trying to race each other. Quite apart from the safety issues explained above, none of us think it would have been possible for a Driver to do this.

10. Unlike in a pit lane (which has an obvious and clearly marked entrance and exit) there was no clear physical marker on the race track for where any speed limit should begin or end at Turn 13. In a pit lane, we race to and from well-defined lives, and we are aware precisely when to brake and when to accelerate so as to maintain race speed before and after the pit. In Turn 13, we would and could not have known when and where to brake and when and where to accelerate to achieve the speed restriction through the Turn. Each Driver would have had to make a judgement which would have been different on each lap depending on what was happening in the race, It would have been quite impossible for any of us to know each time whether or not we have maintained the speed restriction.

11. We also believe that it would also have been impossible for the Stewards or anyone else to tell at Turn 13 precisely when any car had slowed, and whether it complied with the speed limit throughout the restricted area.

12. For those reasons, we have no doubt that a speed restriction imposed at Turn 13 would have been impossible to comply with and impossible to police.

The day of the Grand Prix

13. On the morning of the Grand Prix, all of the Drivers attended a Drivers' briefing with representatives of the Teams. We were told of the Michelin tyre problem. Even though we all wanted to race, we accepted that the Michelin Teams could not go against the safety advice from Michelin and take the risk of serious and potentially fatal accidents.

14. We were also told of the proposal for a chicane at Turn 13. Chicanes have been successfully introduced in races in the past. We believe that a chicane would have been a perfectly workable solutions in Indianapolis. Accordingly none of us objected to a chicane at the meeting.

15. Many of us were also consulted by our Teams about the FIA proposal for a speed restriction. Those who were consulted explained to their Teams that a speed restriction would not work because it would be dangerous and impractical (for the reasons set out above). The Teams in turn explained this to the FIA officials.

Conclusion

16. All of us wanted to have a proper race at Indianapolis, which is one of motor racing's most sacred venues, and to showcase Formula One to the American public. We are all extremely disappointed that we were unable to do this.

23 June 2005

Signed by the following drivers (in alphabetical order):

Christijan Albers
Fernando Alonso
Jenson Button
David Coulthard
Pedro de la Rosa
Giancarlo Fisichella
Patrick Friesacher
Nick Heidfeld
Christian Klien
Felipe Massa
Juan Pablo Montoya
Kimi Raikkonen
Takuma Sato
Ralf Schumacher
Jarno Trulli
Jacques Villeneuve
Ricardo Zonta
Mark Webber
Alexander Wurz
Ricardo Zonta

related:

Michelin F1 Ticket Refund Update: Stubbed Ticket Claim Form Available
Guilty Verdict Cancelled by the FIA WMSC
Michelin, IMS Roll Out Ticket Refund Process For F1 Fans
FIA Senate recommends cancelling the guilty verdict
Appeal to be heard on September 28th
FIA Press conference with Max Mosley
Joint Statement by 19 F1 drivers
Submissions on behalf of 6 Formula One Teams
Joint Statement from 6 Michelin teams
The 7 Michelin teams found guilty on 2 counts
FIA responds to Michelin's statement
Michelin offers a goodwill gesture to the US GP spectators
Michelin concludes its investigation concerning US GP tyres
Max Mosley Statement on the US GP (Q & A format)
FIA list charges against the 7 Michelin teams

Paul Stoddart's account of events at US GP

FIA summons the seven Michelin teams

Michelin teams Post Race Statement

Michelin Post Race Statement
Statement To Fans By Indianapolis Motor Speedway CEO Tony George

US GP Post Race Quotes - IMS

Michelin Pre-Race Statement
Further Correspondence between Michelin and the FIA prior to the race

Correspondence between Michelin and the FIA prior to the race

2005 United States Grand Prix - Main Page

Back To Top


Google
 
Web NewsOnF1.com
NewsOnF1.net (Forum)

2009 Australian F1 Grand Prix
also Accommodation packages
F1 Tickets
2009 Malaysian F1 Grand Prix
2009 Bahrain F1 Grand Prix
2009 Spanish F1 Grand Prix
2009 Monaco F1 Grand Prix
2009 British F1 Grand Prix
2009 Belgian F1 GP
2009 Abu Dhabi F1 GP
MotoGP Tickets
more Motorsport Tours & Holidays
2009 Clipsal 500 package (Adelaide)

Official 2007 F1 Season Review

Autocourse 2007 Annual

F1 Merchandise US

F1 Merchandise UK

Motorsport Magazines

Formula 1 Annuals

Formula 1 Yearbooks

Formula 1 Season Reviews

Formula 1 Technical Books

Formula 1 Design Books

The Official Tribute To Ayrton Senna
1960 To 1994

Chariot Makers: Assembling the Perfect Formula 1 Car

The Science of
F1 Design

Formula 1 Books

Race Driving Books

Race Car Design Books


Ayrton Senna

Past Formula 1 Drivers